102 Comments
User's avatar
Eleanor Cording-Booth's avatar

I've had some suggestions come in via Instagram, so I'll paste them in the comments here to keep everything in one place...

John’s Luncheonette - Classic Diner

Wilfie and Nell - Great bar

The Odeon - Martini and dinner

The Greenwich Hotel - Breakfast

Emilio’s Ballato - Meatballs!

Milano’s Bar - Dive bar

Joe’s Pizza

Birds of a Feather - Amazing Chinese

3 Decker Diner - Pancakes

Dudleys - Brunch

Katz Deli - A classic

Le Dive - Cocktails

L’industrie Pizzeria

Leon’s Bagels - Quick breakfast

Taqueria Ramirez - Tacos, the best

Caffé Panna - Desert

Radio Bakery - Get it all

Hamburger America - Smash burger

Expand full comment
Aurelia Rohrbacker's avatar

I second these recco’s!

Expand full comment
Agathe Karsenti's avatar

Hey ! First : congratulations on this anniversary, 10 years, this is something !!

Second : I spent a month in New York this summer, and walked a lot !!!!

Here are my fav walk I did :

- west side highway : I went during the day to read a book or in the evening to watch the sunset and once to have a pizza from L’Industrie

- I walked around Brooklyn Heights, and tried lappartment 4F, as a French, I can say it’s good bread and croissant ! Cute shop : Salter House !

Also a beautiful sunset view from the piers

Closer to Dumbo : lunch at Usagi was nice !

Once thing I loved was taking the ferries, to governor island and to Red hook, or simply from Brooklyn to manhattan.

My favourite coffee shops :

Sey coffee (Bushwik)

Partner’s coffee shop on Williamsburg

La Cabra, though it was a little too crowded, they still have good coffee and pastries

The coffee shop on the Bandir Shop

Saint George was really nice to chill

Rosecrans was intriguing, with all the flowers, it’s a nice set up.

Lê Phin : the most insane matcha, ask the owner what they recommend, it’s delicious

Loved the cookie from From Lucie

The tomato bagel from Apollo Bagel

Sitting in Tompkins Square for a lunch or to read !

I’d say these are my fav fav !!

Can’t wait to read people’s recs !

Enjoy your trip!!!!!

Expand full comment
Plan V. by Pamela Herrera's avatar

This is such a good guide for all of us! Thank you.

Expand full comment
Eleanor Cording-Booth's avatar

Thanks so much! x

Expand full comment
Emily's avatar

A trip to Dia:Beacon gallery is well worth it. The train ride along the Hudson is beautiful and the gallery is 👌🏼

We stayed part of the time at the hoxton in Williamsburg and really rated it. Williamsburg has lots to offer, the hoxton is just the right bank balance side of special, and the breakfast bag they hang on your door is a lovely touch for a quick start to the day and a hop on the ferry.

Expand full comment
Joana Joana Joana's avatar

I second Dia Beacon, which my lover and I always referred as Dear Beacon. worth it for the trip and best contemporary art.

Expand full comment
Amy's avatar

Zitomer's is a Upper East Side department/pharmacy that is both smaller and bigger than you think it is, full of local flavor, a very particular UES blend of fancy and un-fancy, and a great place to shop for combs. A good stop-in if you're going to the Met.

Argosy is the oldest independent bookstore in NYC, and has a floor full of catalogs of antique prints and bookplates that are wonderful to look through.

Both are not where you're going to go for fancy design, but both are special, are good for finding unique mementos of your trip, not overly touristy, and products of their exact place and time.

Expand full comment
JoAnn's avatar

Seconding Argosy! The basement floor has some good gems.

Expand full comment
Lauren Hildreth's avatar

I’m so glad you mentioned Zitomer!! A must-see spot.

Expand full comment
Sophie Roberts's avatar

I also haven’t been since 2019 so some of my recs are likely wildly out of date, but my favourite experiences last time were:

- going to the Russian Turkish baths in the east village (perfect on a cold, gloomy day) followed by dinner at Superiority Burger,

- getting my aura photographed at Magic Jewellery in Chinatown, followed by lunchtime soup dumplings at Deluxe Green Bo,

- a long afternoon browsing in Dashwood books (all photography books), Bonnie Slotnick Cookbooks, Codex (classics and amazing art books) casa magazines and Iconic magazines

- I love weird highly specialist stores so I loved wandering around Kalustyan’s, the compleat sculptor, economy candy, Kremer Pigments, ninth Avenue international foods

Have a great time!

Expand full comment
Sophie Roberts's avatar

Oh! And years ago I tried to go to the Guggenheim but picked the one day it was closed, so ended up at the Neue Galerie near by and wandered around lapping up all their German and Austrian art (Klimt! schiele!) and then ate an excellent piece of sacher torte in their cafe. Highly recommend.

Expand full comment
Oriana's avatar

Economy candy is so fun

Expand full comment
Eleanor Cording-Booth's avatar

Thank you for all of the tips so far! I can't wait to work my way through these and hope everyone finds them helpful. I've been sent a couple of links to NY guides written by others, so I'll add those here...

- A couple of NY guides from The Anna Edit https://theannaedit.substack.com/p/everything-i-wore-last-week-a-trip and here https://www.theannaedit.com/we-went-to-new-york-heres-our-updated-city-guide/

- A NY guide from my friend Mads at Studio Bust (a wonderful female-founded small business creating bespoke sculptures) https://www.studiobust.com/journal/new-york-city-guide

Expand full comment
Fiona Anderson's avatar

I also recommend a day trip to Dia: Beacon via train. I go there every time I visit New York.

Expand full comment
Lauren Hildreth's avatar

I lived in New York for 13+ years and recently moved to Hudson with my husband and our cats. One thing in restaurant culture that has changed quite a bit is that you really need a reservation if you want to spend your time dining or sightseeing rather than searching or waiting for a table. So start Resy and OpenTable accounts, make a bunch of reservations at places that look interesting (even double-booking slots), then as your itinerary starts coming together, cancel what you don’t need.

My specific NYC suggestions include:

- Historic bagel place: Russ & Daughters, founded in 1914, is one of the city’s few remaining “appetizing” shops. The original takeaway shop is on Houston St., and there’s a beautiful cafe with table service a couple blocks away on Orchard St. (This is on the Lower East Side.)

- See a movie at Metrograph, a restored movie theater not far from Russ & Daughters. They show an array of films from the collection, usually not current stuff.

- Bite-sized museum: The Morgan Library: The closest we’ll ever get to anything like Sir John Soane’s house! The permanent collection includes a copy of the Gutenberg Bible as well as a very cool/scary room-sized safe. Don’t miss whatever the current art exhibit is upstairs. (37th St & Madison Ave.)

- After the Morgan: M&J Trimming on 37th St and 6th Ave is an old-school ribbon and notions shop with the most incredible inventory. Just look at the photos on Google and you’ll see what I mean!

- See a jazz show & Mezzrow (West Village) — buy tickets in advance!

Other restaurants & cafes:

- The Odeon (Tribeca)

- The Waverly Inn (West Village)

- Té Company (West Village)

- Sant Ambroeus (Upper East Side) for a cappuccino at the espresso bar

Shops:

- Casa Magazines (West Village)

- Zitomer (Upper East Side)

- The Locavore Variety store carries only products that were made within 100 miles of NYC. (West Village)

- Canal Lighting & Parts (SoHo)

- Joanne Hendricks Cookbooks

- Left Bank Books

Expand full comment
Peabody Bites's avatar

If going to Russ and Daughters, which I highly recommend, I would also go to The Tenement Museum which is a fascinating slice back through time into the LES

Expand full comment
claire matern's avatar

Sadly M&J closed--it was such a gem of the Garment District. I second the Morgan though!

Expand full comment
Azora Zoe Paknad's avatar

*Rubs hands together*. 12 years here in NYC! I'd love to hear your Edinburgh recommendations as well if you have any, I'm headed that way for the first time.

I'd spend no more than 2 days upstate. I drive typically, but you can take the Metro North to Hudson.

Americans do kind of expect tips on EVERYTHING. But it will always be clear to you when to tip or not, because they will prompt you to.

A lot of the recommendations that came in via Instagram are DEEPLY overhyped. (99% of them.) You may struggle to get in to them, if it doesn't work out, I wouldn't wait in a long line or freeze outside waiting.

Overhyped list: Pop Up Bagels (if you do go, make it a weekday), Leon's Bagels, Joe's Pizza (legitimately bad!), Radio Bakery (they are so mean!), Hamburger America, Caffe Panna (delicious but this is a 100% outdoor experience, you wait in a long line outside and then there is nowhere to eat your ice cream-- not realistic in winter), Wilfie and Nell (can't believe this hook up bar for 24 year olds was recommended to you!), Apollo Bagel, Partner's Coffee, Bernie's, Misi.

Underhyped (or adequately hyped!) things that I deeply recommend!: The Odeon or a reservation at Balthazar. An espresso at Sant Ambroeus on the Upper East, preferably after a snowy Central Park walk or day at The Met (best museum). Brooklyn Ball Factory makes an out of this world matcha latte. Long Island Bar (get there early and have drinks and a burger! Enjoy the people watching). Lilia for Italian (try to put your name in early or right at opening). Eat a cruller and a breakfast sandwich at Daily Provisions. For a classic NY experience, try Peter Pan Donut (an old haunt with the prices to match) and their honey dip or honey cruller and bacon egg and cheese. Drinks at any of the classic NYC fancy bars-- Bemelman's at the Carlyle or King Cole Bar at the St Regis, both of which get busy during prime time. A cheeseburger at JG Melon afterwards (cash only) is DIVINE. Librae Bakery and Hani's Bakery in the Gramercy/Cooper Sq area.

Vintage shopping: CRAZY overpriced in New York. Highway robbery. The best cheap places to go are L Train vintage or their huge outpost, Urban Jungle in Bushwick. Come hydrated and with lots of energy. I also like Fantasy Explosion in Greenpoint for menswear/streetwear and Stella Dallas 10 Ft Single in Williamsburg.

Great neighborhoods to walk: Gramercy Park thru Irving Place. Williamsburg up to Greenpoint. Franklin Avenue in Greenpoint. Museum Mile uptown.

Tourist traps: All of Soho. Anything you see on Instagram or TikTok (unfortunately).

Take the subway everywhere! Ubers are for chumps and wayyyyyy overpriced.

I recommend Gaby Scelzo's newsletter, Perfect City.

Expand full comment
Holly Becker / Decor8's avatar

Omg 10 ft Single by Stella Dallas and Stella Dallas Living are still around!?! I went to 10 ft Single by Stella Dallas in 2011 and LOVED IT. I was with my very stylish London photographer Debi Treloar and she went crazy there too. Yeah that’s a definite must.

Expand full comment
Azora Zoe Paknad's avatar

yup!!

Expand full comment
Eleanor Cording-Booth's avatar

LOVE the overhyped and adequately hyped lists! So helpful - thank you 🙏🏻

Expand full comment
Bella Darden's avatar

For Museums, when you're in NYC, visit the Noguchi Museum and Garden in Queens! The New York Transit Museum in Brooklyn is amazing too. You can spend an hour or so perusing the old subway cars and the subway ads from the past 100 years. The advertisements are unbelievable and you’ll feel like you’re in an episode of Mad Men. Salon 94 is a great space on the UES.

Expand full comment
Carly's avatar

The New York Transit museum is on my list for our next visit. Looks right up my street :)

Expand full comment
JoAnn's avatar

Congrats on 10 years!

New Yorker here ...

- For quirky, interesting shops and restaurants/bars, Nolita and LES is where it's at, especially along Orchard Street. Highly rec November 19 for homeware/gifts, Susan Alexandra for beaded stuff, Coming Soon for homewares. There's also the pickle bookstore. For food, Scarr's for pizza, Katz's for Jewish deli (but go earlyish - long lines/ticketing system), Trappizzino for arancini, Golden Diner, Thai Diner. Note- the Bode store is on Hester Street, it's good for a look, but tbh they're kind of snobby so YMMV (i'm saying this as a Bode devotee).

- Cafe China (W. 37th St/6th Ave) for really amazing Chinese food (the best dandan noodles in the city) near Bryant Park in a very pretty setting (reminds me of a Wong Kar Wai film). Also on same block as Magazine Cafe, which has a ton of fashion/home magazines and international titles.

- Underrated museums: Morgan Library Museum (height of Gilded Age wealth) and The Met Cloisters (medieval church with lots of medieval/Renaissance era tapestries).

- Underrated experience: Happy Medium Art Cafe. You can do a small craft (collage, beading, drawing0, or sign up for a larger thing like a giant painting or a table lamp.

I would NOT recommend:

- Times Square (unless you're seeing a show- and then I would recommend spending time in Hell's Kitchen for dinner/drinks. Pure Thai and Ariana Afghan are food favorites).

- Fifth Avenue for shopping (too $$$ and not impressive tbh).

- Rockefeller Center is crowded AF (but there are some good things there now -- McNally Jackson books, Lodi, and believe it or not the American Girl Cafe has a good birthday package (though a bizarre, surreal experience as you'll be sitting with dolls. And it's close to MOMA.)

- Bad Roman: It's very TikTok famous but tbh it's just fine? I would rather try to score a table at Via Carota.

Expand full comment
Sam Palmer's avatar

For food you have to try Thai Diner!

Expand full comment
Rosie's avatar

Seconding this, Thai Diner is amazing!

Expand full comment
Oriana's avatar

Thirding Thai Diner!

Expand full comment
Flora Somogyi's avatar

It's not cheap... but Gramercy Tavern for food is worth every penny. No need to book the Dining Room, the Tavern has amazing food too. Would be perfect for a 10-year anniversary.

Expand full comment
Lauren Hildreth's avatar

I second this! Everyone sort of forgets about Gramercy, but it’s so great.

Expand full comment
CC's avatar

Thirding. So many places have fallen off or the service is awful. I’ve started going back to Gramercy and also Union Square Cafe because they are so solid.

Expand full comment
GV's avatar

I’m useless when it comes to recommending anything cool as I barely leave my home but I can recommend lots of things to avoid! My biggest advice is to avoid any place you’ve ever seen on social media. They all suck and we’ve lost so many former favorite restaurants to TikTok crowds. For a very cost effective meal, you’re always welcome to dine at our place!

Did you guys do Woodstock last time? I think I remember you skipped it but that’s the best upstate town (despite being the most touristy). It just has so much more going on and has such a fun quirky vibe. We’ve found pretty much every other town dead and depressing in comparison.

We pretty much always do an airbnb but there are a handful of cute hotels too. The Woodstock Way hotel seems really cute and has a pretty setting right in town. Oh and the Twin Gables B&B was cute in a dorky old lady sort of way when we stayed there 374848 years ago!

I always prefer being in a car than on public transportation, and it’s much more romantic too! Rent in the city!

Expand full comment
Eleanor Cording-Booth's avatar

We did go to Woodstock but just for the day, we didn’t stay overnight there. Which TikTok faves do I need to strike off my list?

Expand full comment
GV's avatar

I’m not sure what’s on your list but we used to love Vic’s which recently went down the tubes and has become full of 20 years olds photographing the bathroom wallpaper. Lafayette is a shitshow of people lining up outside for their pastries. Carbone gave me food poisoning so bad I wore a pad to work just in case I shit myself. Let me know what’s on your list and I’ll tell you if any are sure to disappoint!

Expand full comment
Eleanor Cording-Booth's avatar

😂 the pad

And I definitely will!

Expand full comment
claire matern's avatar

I know you said bars not needed but there are some great new non alc bars in NY

- Mockingbird in Park Slope, Brooklyn just opened this past weekend.

-Hekate in the East Village has been around a couple years.

Also great NA bottle shops, my favourite is Minus Moonshine in Prospect Heights.

Another lesser known museum and a favourite of mine is the Merchant's House on E.4th Street

between Lafayette and the Bowery. A preserved 1835 townhouse where only one family lived.

There's also a new gallery space owned by NYU just around the corner from the Merchant's House at 18 Cooper Sq. It's free entry and great exhibitions (currently one that celebrates the collection of Parisian art dealer Berte Weill)

Expand full comment
Sydney Hershenhorn's avatar

practically: bring very comfortable walking shoes and an umbrella in case it rains. Wear layers and bring a tote with you so you can carry everything. The best way to experience nyc is to walk and subway — just be prepared if you’re taking the train during rush hour for it to be crowded. Check Resy for more popular places because some spots you should book out almost a month in advance to get in.

Go to the west village and get pizza at Mama’s Too and L’industrie (same block), and if you’re here during the week go to the more touristy spots during weekdays mid-day because it’ll be less crowded. Highly recommend going to Greenpoint and walking around one day. Kettl is the best for matcha lattes, Acre has great bento box lunches, and for more of a sit down meal go to Rule of Thirds and don’t sleep on their brunch pancake.

The union square farmers market is also great people watching and fun to walk around in spring. The east village has lots of lesser known (at least for people from out of town) fun spots to eat like Superiority Burger, Mala Project, Rosella… there are so many

Also, generally, be prepared to spend more money than you think you will lol

Expand full comment